Have you tried the following:
1. unplug both ATI tuners
2. turn on the windows firewall
3. reboot the machine
4. plug in the tuners
5. re run set-up in MC but do it windowed just incase the firewall is putting up a block message you can't see if full screen.
Is you system an upgrade from Vista or clean install? An OEM machine or bios loader?
XPS420: Quad, 4 Gig, 650/1Tx2 internal, eSata Tower
Dual ATI Cable Cards (SA-800 M) TAs
T-W W Valley (LA)--Win7
ATI Radeon HD3870 (DVI/HDMI)
2 XP, 1 Macintosh X (10.4.11), HP 280N extender, Linksys DMA2100, DMA2200
Promise Ns4300 Raid 5